Independent California insurance brokerage562-268-9355   Agency 6013787
Menu
BusinessPersonalPodcastAbout UsBlog
The Bollinger family together at a California harbor

Speaking of Insurance · Episode 35

Term vs Whole Life Insurance in California: Matching the Policy to the Need

Aaron Bollinger · 15 min. Listen here, review the show notes, or read the transcript before bringing the question to a licensed Bollinsure broker.

Listen to this episode
Three generations in California insuranceNamed licensed broker5.0 on Google, 29 reviews

About this episode

What the conversation covers.

Two neighbors in Simi Valley, both 35, both married with two young kids, buy a $1 million life insurance policy on the same day. One pays about the cost of a streaming bundle each month. The other pays more than a car payment. Neither one got ripped off. They bought two different tools for two different jobs.

Aaron Bollinger of Bollinsure Insurance Services compares term life and whole life insurance for California families. We cover how each one works, what you actually pay for, the cash value question, the policy provisions that matter, a few California consumer protections, and three examples that show how to match the type of coverage to how long the need lasts.

What we cover:

  • The real question: how long does the need last, and what else should the policy do
  • How term life works: level term, what happens after the level period, and conversion privileges
  • Riders: waiver of premium and accelerated death benefits
  • Laddering term policies so coverage steps down as the mortgage shrinks
  • How whole life works: guaranteed cash value, dividends from mutual insurers, and why early years grow slowly
  • Policy loans, surrender charges, and the MEC rule (the seven pay test)
  • California protections: the 60 day grace period and lapse notice designee, the free look period, and the guarantee association
  • Underwriting, exclusions, the contestable period, and how death claims get paid
  • Examples: a young family in Oxnard, a lifelong special needs plan, and a Ventura buy-sell
  • Buy term and invest the difference, blending term and permanent, and a checklist before you talk to a broker

Resources:

Clarifications

  • Around 3:03 the word spoken as "writers" means riders: optional add-ons such as waiver of premium and an accelerated death benefit.
  • Around 9:49: the California Life and Health Insurance Guarantee Association protects policies from insurers licensed (admitted) in California, up to set limits. Non-admitted or surplus lines carriers are not covered by it.
  • Laddering means owning several term policies with different lengths, as in the $750,000 30 year plus $750,000 15 year example around 3:25. Pairing a large term policy with a smaller permanent policy, mentioned around 14:33, is usually called blending.
  • The opening example takes place in Simi Valley.
  • To reach us by phone, use the number below.

Get quoted: Compare coverage options with Bollinsure Insurance Services at www.bollinsure.com/quote , or call 562-268-9355 .

CA License 6013787

This episode is for general education only and is not legal, tax, or coverage advice. Coverage, eligibility, and pricing depend on the carrier, underwriting, and your policy terms.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Cold open: same coverage, two very different prices
  • 00:25 Welcome and what this episode covers
  • 01:30 What life insurance is for
  • 01:57 How term life works
  • 02:35 Conversion privileges and riders
  • 03:25 Laddering term policies
  • 03:58 How whole life works and cash value
  • 06:14 Early years, loans, and the MEC rule
  • 08:04 Grace period, beneficiaries, and California protections
  • 10:07 Underwriting, exclusions, and death claims
  • 11:56 When it goes wrong: the contestable period
  • 12:32 Three examples
  • 13:41 Matching the type to the need and buy term, invest the difference
  • 14:38 Your checklist and four questions
  • 15:22 Getting help and sign-off

Transcript excerpt

Two neighbors, both 35, both married with two young kids, buy a $1 million life insurance policy on the same day. One pays about the cost of a streaming bundle each month. The other pays more than a car payment. Neither one got ripped off. They bought two different tools for two different jobs. Today we're going to figure out which job you are actually hiring life insurance to do.… Full episode on bollinsure.com

Get quoted

Watch the clips

Short videos from this conversation.

ep35-c1
Read the episode transcript
Aaron Bollinger (00:00) Two neighbors in Simi Valley, both 35, both married with two young kids, buy a $1 million life insurance policy on the same day. One pays about the cost of a streaming bundle each month. The other pays more than a car payment. Neither one got ripped off. They bought two different tools for two different jobs. Today, we're going to figure out which job you are actually hiring life insurance to do. Hello, everybody, and welcome back to the Speaking of Insurance podcast. Aaron Bollinger (00:28) My name is Aaron Bollinger. Today we are comparing term life and whole life insurance. We'll cover how each one works, what you actually pay for, the cash value question, the policy provisions that matter, a few California consumer protections, and three real-world style examples. On our blog, we have already covered why the age you buy matters, so today is going to be about choosing the type. Quick disclaimer before we start, this episode is general education only. It is not legal, tax, investment, or financial device. Aaron Bollinger (00:58) Policy details, pricing, and eligibility will depend on the insurance company and on underwriting. For tax questions, talk to a CPA or a tax professional. Here is a number worth sitting with. LIMRA and LifeHappens run a yearly study on life insurance ownership, and it keeps finding the same pattern. Roughly half of American adults own any life insurance at all, and a large share of them say they do not have enough. One of the most common reasons people give for not buying is that they think that it costs far more than it does. So we're going to be comparing the types and agreeing on the purpose. Life insurance replaces money that disappears when someone dies. That might be income that pays a mortgage, child care, college, or a business partner's share. Aaron Bollinger (01:43) The question is not term or whole life. In the abstract, the question is how long does this need to last and what else do I want the policy to do? That is the point of insurance, the function of insurance. It has to be tailored to you and your circumstances. Term life, luckily, is very simple. You pick a death benefit and a term. Commonly, it's 10, 20, 30 years. You pay a premium. If you die during the term, your beneficiaries receive the death benefit, generally income tax free. If you outlive the term, the coverage ends and there is no payment and no cash value. Most term policies sold today are level term. That means the premium stays the same for the whole term. After the level period ends, many policies let you keep going, but the premium usually jumps up sharply each year. Makes sense. They get you on the hook. It's like a subscription. Then you're hooked and they up the price. In practice, most people let the policy lapse or replace it entirely. Aaron Bollinger (02:35) Two features to look for on a term policy. The first is the conversion privilege. Many term policies let you convert some or all of the coverage into a permanent policy without new medical questions up to a certain age or within a certain window. This matters a lot if your health changes and with the conversion deadline and which permanent products you can convert to. Again, this would just be like a way of you keeping the life insurance company on the hook in the event that something does happen in terms of your health subject to conditions. The second though is riders. Common riders on insurance policies include a waiver of premium if you become disabled and an accelerated death benefit that lets you access part of the benefit if you are diagnosed with a terminal illness. Some carriers include the accelerated benefit at no extra charge. And so this might already be on your insurance policy or you might have to add it. Definitely something worth thinking about. One more term detail people miss is laddering. Instead of buying one, one and a half million dollar policy 30 years, a family might buy a $750,000 30-year policy Aaron Bollinger (03:37) plus a $750,000 15-year policy. The coverage steps down as the mortgage shrinks and the kids grow up and the total premium is often lower. The trade-off is more policies to track and each one has its own conversion deadline. So when you're coordinating two separate insurance policies, of course, it'll be more different in terms of the way that it acts as opposed to a holistic policy. And a word on price perception, industry surveys have found for years that most adults overestimate the cost of a basic term policy, often by two to three times. If you have put off buying because you've assumed that life insurance on term policies is expensive, get a real number before you decide it is huge and could be a very big benefit to your family. So why is term so much cheaper? Because most term policies never pay a death claim. People outlive them. The insurer prices that in, and you get a lot of protection per dollar that you pay for premium. Whole life is permanent insurance. As long as you pay the premiums, the coverage lasts for your whole life. Aaron Bollinger (04:38) The premium is usually fixed and guaranteed not to increase. Whole life also builds cash value. Part of each premium goes into a reserve that grows at a guaranteed rate set in the contract. So you're like pooling up a bunch of money essentially and getting a set rate of interest to guaranteed rate that's in the contract. With a participating policy from a mutual insurer, you might also receive dividends. Dividends are not guaranteed, but some companies have paid them for decades. And so getting with an insurance company that does that for you could sweeten the pot. You can use cash value in a few ways. You can borrow against it with a policy loan. You can use dividends to buy more coverage or reduce your premium, or you can surrender the policy for its cash surrender value. Here are the trade-offs, which I would say to completely keep into consideration when you're making this decision. One is cost. For the same death benefit, whole life premiums often run many times higher than term, especially at those younger ages. Some Aaron Bollinger (05:39) people end up underinsured because they buy the amount of whole life they can afford instead of the amount of coverage that their family would need in the event that they were to die. It makes sense, right? Especially for those younger folk who maybe are the breadwinner for their family. I'm younger as well, but people 30, 40, 50, maybe not 50. My dad's 50 and he calls himself old. No offense. But people 30 to 40, if you're looking to buy a whole life insurance policy, obviously these insurance companies are going to price in the fact that they're going to be on the hook for your whole life. And so eligibility and things like that can be a bit tricky and you got to go obviously get an insurance broker to take a look. Number two, I would say is early years. Aaron Bollinger (06:16) Cash value usually grows slowly at first because commissions and policy costs are front-loaded. If you surrender in the first several years, you might get back far less than you paid in, which would obviously not be a high ROI. Many policies also have surrender charges for those early years as well to discourage people from taking out money early and really try and get you to consistently pay. Number three is that loans are not free. An unpaid policy loan plus interest reduces the death benefit. It makes sense. If the loan grows larger, than the cash value, the policy, of course, can lapse. And that can create a tax bill on the gain. Aaron Bollinger (06:52) You do not want a tax bill on the gain. If the loan grows larger and the policy... Number four is the MEC rule. If you put too much money into a policy too quickly, it can fail a federal test called the seven-pay test and become a modified endowment contract or an MEC. A MEC still pays a death benefit, but loans and withdrawals get less favorable tax treatment. This mostly matters for people paying extra premium on purpose. Your agent and your CPA should check that to make sure that it is set up properly. Some provisions show up on both policy types and they matter at claim time. The contestability period is a big one. For the first two years a policy is enforced, the insurer can generally contest the policy if there is a material misrepresentation on your application. Basically, answer the medical and lifestyle questions honestly. Aaron Bollinger (07:46) A missed doctor visit or a forgotten prescription can cause real trouble on a claim in year one or year two or others. The suicide exclusion is a very big one as well, very topical. It's that most policies exclude suicide in the first two years, and they usually refund the premiums instead of paying the benefit. The others include the grace period, the beneficiary designations, the beneficiary designations. Name primary and contingent beneficiaries and update them after a marriage, divorce, or birth. Minors generally cannot receive the proceeds directly, so many families name a trust or set up a custodian, somebody to get that money and then hand it off to the child. If you miss a payment, there is a grace period before the policy lapses. California has added notice protections for individual life insurance policies. They must give you a 60-day grace period and allow you to name someone like an adult child to receive a lapse notice. That second notice has saved a lot of policies for older policyholders who might not be up to date Aaron Bollinger (08:46) on their mail or email. Another one is the free look. In California, after you receive a new individual life policies, you have a free look period to review it and return it for a refund. It is generally 10 days and longer 30 days for applicants who are 60 or older. So if you are older again, you're maybe not good on the email checkup, and maybe the mail gets lost every once in a while. It happens to my dad, and he's not even 60. Sorry, dad. Basically, what we're trying to say is that you do get an extra 20 days of time to get that free look period and potentially return for a refund if you realize that you don't want it. One more California safety net. Aaron Bollinger (09:21) If a life insurer licensed in California becomes insolvent, the California Life and Health Insurance Guarantee Association provides protection up to set limits. It's a backstop, not a reason to pick a weak insurance company. Check the insurance company's financial strength before you go rely on this California guarantee. Last podcast or two podcasts ago, we had talked about the California guarantee for home insurance as well. For excess insurance companies, obviously that would not apply. For the admitted companies, they would cover up to a specific threshold of coverage, which continuously I'm sure will change. But for life insurance, before we get into the examples, let's talk about what happens at the start and end, because that's where most of these problems that we're discussing live. At the start, it's the underwriting period. They place you in a rate class, often called preferred plus, preferred standard, or a table rating based on your health, family history, driving record, habits, tobacco and nicotine use, of course, vaping, some of the time that usually doubles the premium or more. Many insurance companies now offer accelerated Aaron Bollinger (10:25) underwriting with no exam for healthy applicants up to certain ages and amounts using prescription and medical databases the speed is real so is the duty to answer honestly because those databases are checked again at claim time if you die in the first two years don't misrepresent next the exclusions and ratings beyond suicide some policies exclude or charge extra for private aviation scuba diving below certain depths motorsports or climbing if you're doing crazy adventurous stuff you've got to make sure that it's explicitly stated or understood by the insurance company and covered a few even still have war exclusions so those those of you with hazardous hobbies make sure it's included or if it's excluded weigh the pros and cons of continuing that a flat extra premium is usually better than an exclusion come the event that something does happen to the person who the coverage is intended for at the end though is the death claim the beneficiary sends the insurer a claim form and a certified death certificate. In a clean claim Aaron Bollinger (11:25) outside the contestable period, payments often come within a few weeks, hopefully. California law requires insurers to pay interest on death benefits from the date of death if payment is delayed. Makes sense. It's like these smoke claims and these new bits of legislation that are happening onto insurance companies and the property insurance markets. It's the same for life insurance. You've got to pay these people out in the event that something does happen. If the death happened inside the first two years, expect the insurer to request medical records before paying. Here's how it can go wrong. Let's say that Alex, 41, buys a $750,000 term policy and does not mention a recent visit for chest pain and a prescription for blood pressure medication. Aaron Bollinger (12:07) 18 months later, he dies of a heart attack. The insurer reviews his record during the contestable period, finds the omission, and just completely eliminates the policy, returning the premiums instead of paying the death benefit. Had he disclosed it, he likely would have been approved for a standard rate or a higher premium, but his family would have been paid. Obviously, it's very sad to talk about these examples. These are not based on real people. These are just illustrative, but let's go one by one. Let's start with Jordan in Oxnard, who has a 30-year mortgage and two kids under five. Family would need about 12 years of his income to cover the mortgage and raise the kids. The need is large, and it shrinks, of course, over time as the mortgage gets paid down and the kids hopefully become less needy. A 20 or 30 year level term policy sized at a multiple of his current income would fit the job of covering him. If Jordan also wants some permanent coverage later, a convertible term policy keeps that door open without another separate medical exam. Example number two could be a couple who have a child with special needs who require support for life. That need will never go away. Permanent coverage, often whole life, Aaron Bollinger (13:09) or a guaranteed universal life policy can make sense here. Frequently owned by special needs trust set up with an attorney. So make sure that you get that trust set up as well. Example number three, two co-owners of Ventura Landscaping Company want to buy-sell agreement so that the surviving owner can buy out the deceased owner's family's interests. Makes sense. Term insurance can work for a business that both owners plan to sell within 20 years. Permanent coverage can make sense when the plan is to run the business until death. Aaron Bollinger (13:38) That decision should involve a business attorney and the CPA. Notice the pattern. The right type of insurance follows the length of the need. You've probably heard the phrase, buy term and invest the difference. The idea is to buy cheaper term coverage and invest the money you save into a retirement account or a brokerage account. It can work very well, but with one condition. You actually have to invest the difference every month for decades. Many people don't. Whole life's four savings and guarantees appeal to people who value certainty and discipline over potential returns. Aaron Bollinger (14:08) So my honest take would be this. I would say that for most young families with a mortgage and kids, term covers the core need at a price that's sustainable. Permanent coverage earns its place for lifelong needs like special needs planning, estate business situations, final expenses, tax-advantaged assets. Some people use both, a big term policy for the income years plus a smaller permanent life policy for the needs that never end. Insurance professionals call that laddering or blending the insurance coverages. Here's what to gather before you talk to a broker, your checklist, five things, your debts, include your mortgage balance, years left, future goals, college or care for a parent, maybe. I would say any existing coverage, obviously, if you do have insurance currently, group life through work. Remember that group coverage often ends when you leave the job. So something to keep in mind. And I would say the last thing is your health history and medications. And you can ask the four questions that I love to pose at the end of every podcast. How long does my need last? What is the conversion deadline on this term policy? On a Aaron Bollinger (15:12) whole life quote, what are the guaranteed values versus the illustrated values in decade one and decade two? And what is the insurer's financial strength? If this episode has helped you think about how long your family's needs actually last, start there with a number of years and just a dollar amount. If you would help comparing term and permanent options side by side, you can start at Bollinsure.com slash quote. We like to keep it educational, brief, again, non-transactional, just trying to find out what's best for your family. Again, this episode is for general education only. I'm Aaron Bollinger with Bollinsure Insurance Services. Thank you for listening to Speaking of Insurance, and we will see you all in the next one.

The path

One next step at a time.

  1. 01

    Listen or read

    Use the audio, show notes, and transcript to understand the issue in plain language.

  2. 02

    Identify what applies

    Bring the account, deadline, contract, policy, or underwriting question that makes the topic relevant.

  3. 03

    Review it with a broker

    A licensed Bollinsure broker can separate general information from what applies to the actual risk.

Start here

Turn the episode into a useful next question.

Start the relevant quote path, email the policy or contract question, or book a focused conversation with a licensed Bollinsure broker.